Give each contractor the same job to price
Write a short description of the repair location, the problem and what you want finished. If one bidder saw pictures and another visited, record that difference. Ask each person to confirm the conditions their estimate assumes.
Mark scope items where it is unclear what the contractor included. For a gate repair, note whether the existing posts stay, what hardware would be replaced, who collects the debris and when the gate can be used. Compare answers to the same questions.
Use a fictional repair to compare the details
Quote A lists replacement boards and hinges, disposal and a final adjustment. Quote B lists replacement boards and adjustment with nothing about hinges or disposal. Quote C assumes the post can be reused. If the post needs work, ask how the contractor would decide and price that extra work.
Write “clarify” beside missing details. Ask for a revised total once you have the same scope. Check whether the totals already include materials, taxes, trip charges and finishing work.
| Detail | What to ask |
|---|---|
| Materials | Which boards, hardware and finish are included? |
| Existing post | What condition does the quote assume? |
| Removal | Who takes away old parts and packaging? |
| Change | How will you describe and price extra work before it starts? |
Keep timing and responsibilities visible
Record the earliest start, how long the work should take and how the area will be left between visits. Include who handles access, protection and cleanup. Where a local requirement or approval matters, ask who handles it and check first-party instructions for the location.
Keep the estimate and each answer in the same place. If you ask an assistant to organize the quotes, review the amounts and exclusions against the original files. Twin is developing help for tasks like this.
Send the same questions to each bidder
Identify the estimate by date and ask for an answer in writing. Keep the original and revised totals so you can see which changes caused the difference.
Read back the revised scope before accepting any quote. It helps both sides agree on what a finished repair includes.